These past few weeks have served as a way to apply our
knowledge on DIDLS and close reading. While analyzing The Century Quilt in class, I realized how important DIDLS is.
Because I had its meaning memorized, I was able to go through the poem and pick
out the examples of each one. I didn’t have any problems picking out the
different types of diction, imagery, details, language, and syntax, but I found
it confusing on how to apply them in an explanation of how they affect the work
as a whole. For example I found that the
poem was split into four different time periods: the narrator’s past, the
narrator’s present, the narrators mother’s past, and the narrator’s future; but
I was not able to explain how this affected the work as a whole.
The peer response to the blogs was helpful in that they
opened my eyes on what to do and not to do.
In the open prompt post, I failed to address an important aspect of the
play that would draw Romeo and Mercutio to be more similar not different (which
was my argument). While Romeo bounces between the heights of ecstatic love and
the lows of deepest melancholy, Mercutio continues to act as the voice of
reason. When Romeo is overly idealistic about love Mercutio cautions him
against impulsive action, but when Romeo is despairing about love Mercutio
tells him to think rationally and to pursue Juliet if he truly loves her.
Therefore while Mercutio may seem to be a proponent of passion, he is in fact
still acting as the voice of reason and advocating for Romeo to act upon his
love for Juliet if he truly feels it. And regarding the Queen Mab monologue, I
would state that Mercutio does not necessarily believe in this fairy, but
rather is using the most romantic of poetic language and description to appeal
to Romeo’s romantic nature in order to galvanize him into action. If I had
included this in my essay and had effectively argued it my way, the reader may
have been convinced even though on the surface it seemed the opposite.
This week we also began reading The American Dream. While reading it the first time, I was
extremely confused on Albee’s purpose of writing the play and I felt that he
probably intended it to be read and seen by a more mature audience with greater
life experience. However, after reading the article on how the hardworking but
aging Grandma actually represents the gradual death of the old “American dream”
and the handsome but vapid young man represents the concern with superficiality
and lack of substance of the new “American dream.” This was mind-boggling at
first, but as I started reading closely through the play these ideas made more
sense. Grandma was old, useful, not used to the new social ways, and caring, unlike most people of the next
generation; and while the young man was good looking, he seems to have no useful
purpose in the world.
I feel that the allusion presentations were useful in that
they summarized all the important events in each story so we would not have to
read them individually in order to understand the reference. I have not yet
found any allusions to these stories in the readings we have done in AP Lit,
but I am sure that I will soon.
I have learned how to apply the important aspects of AP Lit,
such as DIDLS and close reading in these past few weeks, and I am excited to
apply them in my future close readings.
You do a really good job in responding to the course material. However, I have noticed that although you thoroughly go through each point, you don't really tie everything together as a whole. For me this is a good way to study, finding connections. I really enjoyed the portion about going back through your blogs after your peer comments. I can really tell that you are reprocessing the material in these posts. Maybe possibly add something regarding how we learned how to read the close reading prompts? It could serve as a helpful reminder come AP exam time.
ReplyDeleteSaloni this is great! I really like how you used examples. Those showed that you really thinking about your response and are not just making things up! I agree with much of what you said. The DIDLS has helped me a lot but of course it can be confusing at times. Your conclusion is something I personally did not do on my "Response to Course Materials" blog. I like it though. It clearly stated your points so I knew exactly what you were trying to say throughout the response!
ReplyDeleteYour length is also quite perfect. It is long enough to where you put a lot of effort into it and addressed all that needed to be said but not to long to where it is overwhelming for the reader. Nice job!